Opens in a new tab

What is the Best Brokerage for Expats?

Expatriate stamp on world map representing international relocation and financial planning.

One of the challenges for expats who leave the United States is that they really can’t effectively take their investments with them. Citizenship-based taxation, the non-portability of retirement accounts (e.g., you can’t “offshore” a qualified retirement account to a foreign custodian) and the passive foreign investment company (PFIC) tax regime, as well as other regulatory/reporting rules, make the proposition for expats taking their nest eggs with them abroad wholly impractical and/or extremely burdensome. It is generally advisable for our expat clients to keep most of their investments stateside (with the notable exceptions of cash and their foreign employer-sponsored pensions, of course).

On the other hand, finding a domestic U.S. custodian that wants to continue to hold and/or manage your investments once you’ve informed them that you no longer live in the United States is not always simple or without its wrinkles. Quite simply put, most U.S. brokerage firms do not accept non-resident customer accounts. Moreover, even if a custodian won’t routinely kick a customer out upon discovering that they no longer live in the U.S., many custodians will curtail communications, advice and, quite possibly, the investment options for the expat customer. No wonder many of expats try to hide their true residence from their U.S. custodians, whether through using a P.O. Box, a remote virtual mail facility, or even a relative or good friend’s physical address. While the frustration is understandable, we don’t advise expats to go down this path of ethical and perhaps even legal ambiguity, but we recognize that the proverbial lay of the custodial land for U.S. expats provides few comfortable alternatives.

Accordingly, this is a genuine attempt to comprehensively look a bit more in depth at the problem, but mainly to dive deeper than we have in past iterations of articles on this subject to provide clearer guidance for U.S. expats to find the best feasible solution for them. As discussed below, there is no obvious solution that fits all expats. The best solution will depend on several factors, including the expat investor’s location in the world, their wealth, their investment objectives, their personality, their investment knowledge, experience and how much time and effort they are willing to commit to monitoring and managing their portfolios.

Why Expats May Not Be Welcome: I’ve had countless conversations with U.S. expats over the years that have received the disappointing news from their incumbent custodian that they can no longer service their account and that their investments need to find a new home. Custodians aren’t usually particularly forthcoming with a detailed explanation of “why” this is happening. I’ve heard unhappy expats cite multiple potential reasons, most of which may hold some merit. In reality, financial institutions all over the world seem to have limited comfort working with Americans that live outside of the United States. Here are three common themes I hear from both expats and from other financial industry professionals regarding the custodial void that U.S. expats experience:

  • Know Your Client (KYC) and Anti Money Laundering (AML) Rules: U.S. financial institutions have long been held to objective standards to understand their customer’s net worth and sophistication levels when recommending financial products, but the Patriot Act truly raised the regulatory standards for financial institutions and magnified the danger of not performing enhanced diligence and monitoring concerning the financial activities of customers. Customers that live abroad are potentially more difficult to know and the sources of funds more difficult to verify, so this may lead many financial institutions to draw a bright red line at the borders for individual clients rather than make tougher and perhaps more subjective decisions on whether to retain a client that moves abroad.
  • Foreign Regulators and “Doing Business” in Foreign Jurisdictions: U.S. financial institutions have plenty of regulations to follow. The SEC, FINRA, the Department of Treasury/IRS, the Department of Labor, etc. seem to justify their budgets and workforces by introducing new rules on at least a semi-regular basis. It’s a lot for compliance and legal departments in financial firms to keep up with. Now imagine working with customers that reside in other countries, many of which have similarly complex and ever-changing rules and regulations. Could servicing a relatively small percentage of customers that happen to live in a handful of these other countries trigger obligations to report to foreign regulators and to demonstrate compliance with all of their rules and regulations on top of the U.S. regulatory burden? 

Doing business in a foreign country certainly could carry these additional burdens, so knowingly servicing residents of other countries can require additional compliance and reporting resources. These domestic financial institutions have to conduct their own cost/benefit analysis when they do business in another country, even with customers that are U.S. citizens. Many of them simply choose not to.  Others choose to limit their foreign ambitions to a region (e.g., Latin America) where they perceive opportunities that more than justify the additional regulatory burdens. Others may venture into serving foreign residents on a country by country basis, evaluating the potential gains versus the potential legal and regulatory exposures in each jurisdiction. Others may have business models where they interact mostly or even solely with other companies that manage the financial affairs of the end customers. When the relationships are of a more institutional nature, there may be lower exposure to the financial regulations of the foreign jurisdiction that are intended to protect the less financially sophisticated. Given these potential outcomes, one begins to understand why financial institutions’ internal policies regarding doing business with U.S. expats can vary greatly and may also evolve over time.

  • The Foreign Account Tax Compliant Act (FATCA): This is a law that was enacted in the U.S. back in 2010. I have to scratch my head a bit when people say that they got the boot from a U.S. bank or brokerage because of FATCA, simply because the “FA” in FATCA stands for “foreign account.”  It’s not DATCA and it really shouldn’t and doesn’t restrict Americans from having domestic U.S. financial accounts. It is most certainly an important reason why many foreign custodians eschew dealing with Americans, because FATCA requires that these foreign institutions directly report financial data on the accounts of Americans, or “suspected” Americans, to the U.S. Treasury Department/IRS. It’s not something that thrills foreign brokerages and banks and the economic penalties for failing to comply with FATCA are harsh. As for domestic banks and brokerages, I sometimes wonder if the compliance departments of many institutions truly understand FATCA or its scope. The conversations I’ve had with compliance personnel in major financial institutions on the topic suggest that there may be quite a few that do not.

The takeaway here is that catering to U.S. expats as a domestic brokerage amplifies risk and complexity. If this was a large enough market for every brokerage, they could scale this submarket by adding the necessary resources to train service associates and adequately staff the international legal and regulatory support required.  However, since U.S. expats are a relatively small cohort compared to U.S. residents, this model has only been adopted by a small minority of brokerage firms that can find enough international business to justify the costs to handle the added risk and complexity.

Why Pooled Investments May Be Off Limits: In addition to finding a brokerage that will accept (and not freeze all purchases) for the expat customer, there may be other limitations or restrictions to contend with even once the U.S. expat has found a safe brokerage solution. Once again, tax and financial industry regulations have led to brokerage company policies that hamper or limit the investment choices that may be available to U.S. expat customers at otherwise accommodating brokerages.  Here are three important examples:

  •  PFIC Tax Regime: This was mentioned in the introduction section, above, but I want to emphasize the dangers of “going native” when moving abroad.  You may be living in a tax haven where only the citizenship-based tax reach of the U.S. government applies, or you may be in Japan, Australia, Germany, the United Kingdom, Spain, Portugal, etc. – U.S. expats are not like other expats and they are not like the indigenous population of any foreign country. Because of the PFIC rules, Americans must avoid pooled investments that are not registered in the United States in their taxable brokerage accounts. In some circumstances, this extends to certain pensions and even certain foreign public pension programs (e.g., provident funds)! You’ve been warned, again. Even when you have access to foreign ETFs or mutual funds at a U.S. brokerage, the PFIC rules apply in taxable brokerage accounts. Be careful out there!
  • U.S. Mutual Funds: A mutual fund is a “prospectus product,” meaning that the fund manager is conducting a perpetual road show and the fund is always in its initial public offering (IPO) stage. The prospectus lays out all the terms of the offering and, routinely, there is language within that prospectus that the product is intended for U.S. residents only. Accordingly, brokerages that serve clients that live outside the United States routinely block access to all U.S. mutual funds to those clients. This doesn’t mean that nonresidents are forced to sell existing shares, but rather they will not have access to either purchasing new shares or reinvesting their distributions from their mutual funds.
  • UK/EU Residents and the MFIDII/PRIPs Regulations: The EU has its own set of rules for pooled investments that include the types of disclosures/prospectuses that must be furnished to its residents. Without going into unnecessary detail, these rules are somewhat antithetical to U.S. rules for U.S. ETFs, mutual funds, interval funds, private equity funds, hedge funds etc. Accordingly, U.S. brokerages may run afoul of these regulations if they permit the purchase of U.S.-registered ETFs and other pooled investments by residents of the EU (and the UK, which has not overwritten these regulations post-Brexit). This applies even to U.S. citizen residents in these countries. Such customers may be limited to investing in individual securities rather than U.S. pooled investments (and please avoid non-U.S. registered pooled investments!!!).

There are additional wrinkles or challenges that U.S. expats may need to contend with that are worth mentioning to highlight further complications that arise from both foreign and domestic laws and/or their limitations: 

  • Special Tax Rules in Certain Countries: These aren’t restrictions on certain investment types per se, but there are multiple countries in the EU that will apply higher tax rates (ordinary income vs. lower portfolio income/capital gains rates) to funds that are not registered in the EU. Italy, Ireland, Denmark, Austria all come to mind. In these instances, a U.S. citizen shouldn’t own EU-registered funds (the PFIC problem), so individual securities are recommended to construct the portfolio. Additionally, the UK has PFIC-type rules for offshore funds, but a large exception for foreign-registered funds that report to the HMRC (their version of the IRS). Accordingly, we invest UK resident clients in U.S.-registered funds that report to the HMRC and/or utilize individual securities when building portfolios.
  • Transfer On Death (TOD) Instructions: While retirement accounts give customers the ability to choose their beneficiaries under federal ERISA rules, this ability migrated to bank and taxable brokerage accounts by way of state law – the passage of the uniform transfer on death statutes that were passed in 49 states (exception: Louisiana). However, if a customer dies while living overseas, transfer on death is not necessarily honored by banks or brokerages, opening the unfortunate specter of prolonged, complex foreign probate and the need to furnish the brokerage or bank with an IRS transfer certificate, which can take as long as two years to obtain once probate is completed! 

For those looking for answers on how to navigate this perplexing issue of finding the best custodial solution for their investments, the potential reasons behind why this is even a problem may seem extraneous. However, as we dive into potential solutions, below, an understanding of these regulations/rules/internal policies should prove useful in navigating the available choices and options – in truly finding the best possible custodial arrangement available to the U.S. expat’s particular situation and preferences.

To effectively find the best custodial options for U.S. expat investors, one needs to bifurcate the landscape in terms of the type of brokerage customer. There is no clear best choice for all U.S. expat investors. 

First, let’s consider the retail investor landscape. By “retail,” I am referring to U.S. expats that manage their own investments. The options here are quite limited, but the better options should be familiar to those who have read our earlier commentaries on this subject. Two choices stand out:

Charles Schwab

While many U.S. brokerages have spent the past 20 years kicking retail clients living outside the United States to the curb, Charles Schwab has seen this as an opportunity to expand its global client footprint. Accounts opened by residents of foreign countries (whether U.S. expats or not) are getting U.S. brokerage (or trust, or retirement) accounts. Access to foreign exchanges and foreign investments is therefore quite limited. Moreover, Schwab does not offer custody in multiple currencies to “international” (non domestic) accounts – these are U.S. dollar-denominated accounts. Schwab is an industry giant, which has gained massive scale through consolidation with several competitors, most notably its somewhat recent merger with TD Ameritrade (which was far less international). Schwab does business with foreign retail clients in a limited number of countries, but that number has expanded significantly over the past few years. It maintains a list of “permitted jurisdictions,” which are the countries where Schwab will open new accounts for retail clients – not just Americans, but any resident of the country that wishes to have U.S. investment accounts. It also maintains a “restricted jurisdictions” list of countries where they will not open new accounts. You can examine the available countries to open a Schwab international account in the dropdown menu of resident country choices found on this page. Moreover, while many EU countries have been added to the permitted jurisdictions list, the MFIDII/PRIPs rules described above apply to retail accounts, so access to all U.S. mutual funds and even ETFs are blocked for customers with UK and EU addresses on file.

Interactive Brokers (IB)

Interactive Brokers (IB) was built to be an affordable and flexible option for international retail customers. It offers access to not just the U.S. exchanges, but most major foreign exchanges, too. It is also a multi-currency platform that allows customers to convert currencies from and to U.S. dollars (USD) from and to most other major world currencies – at spot prices with reasonable transaction fees. It does not allow accounts in every single country a U.S. expat might live in, but IB is open for business in the vast majority of countries, making IB an option in many countries where Schwab is not available. What IB offers in sophistication can be a bit more difficult to navigate for retail customers compared to the retail platforms than they may be accustomed to (i.e., compared to Schwab, Vanguard, Fidelity, Robinhood, Sofi, etc.). From personal experience, I rate customer service below average (sorry). The restrictions on purchasing U.S.-registered funds for UK and EU residents apply uniformly to IB just as they do for retail clients of Schwab. While customers can buy securities in foreign markets (after exchanging for the applicable currency), U.S. citizen clients need to be careful with the PFIC rules. In taxable accounts, avoid the temptation to buy foreign ETFs, closed-end funds, etc. Worse yet, understand that certain individual foreign securities have passive income that can cause them to be classified as a PFIC – good luck trying to determine whether or not they avoid such classification.  With the additional freedom of access to foreign investments comes additional tax pitfalls for unknowing retail investors – be careful out there!

To have a clear picture of the true U.S. investment brokerage landscape for U.S. Expats, we need to dive a little deeper and point out that working with an independent advisor that manages the expat’s portfolio can expand both the available custodians and also the available investment options for the U.S. expat investor. That might sound terribly self-serving coming from an independent advisory firm with advisors that specialize in working with U.S. expat clients, but (a) I don’t make the rules, and (b) these are the rules. This is a landscape that we have navigated, negotiated, and come to understand much, much better over time. Finding and developing relationships that further our mission of providing the very best quality of financial planning and investment management for U.S. expats has been and continues to be a big part of our mission and, like so many other aspects of the cross-border environments we must help clients navigate, it has been a career-long learning experience. Accordingly, it’s rewarding to share some of that acquired knowledge with the larger expat community.

Schwab Alliance

Most people don’t fully appreciate that Schwab is really two brokerages, or should I say two distinct platforms, rolled together in one name.  There is the retail platform, discussed above, which works quite well (with the limitations outlined above) for many U.S clients, where available.  But there is also an institutional platform – Schwab Alliance – which is for clients that work with one or more of the thousands of independent financial advisors that are registered on the Schwab institutional platform. There are advantages to being an institutional client of Schwab, beyond the multitude of advantages of working with a professional advisor that understands the nuances and intricacies of tax efficient investing in your particular cross-border circumstances (promotional flex, again). For example, the restrictions that UK and EU residents face regarding access to U.S.-registered ETFs on the retail platform do NOT apply to the institutional Schwab platform. This is due to the notable exceptions in the EU regulations regarding investments managed by an overseas advisor.

Moreover, while Schwab retail clients may need to be residents of one of the above-mentioned permitted jurisdictions to maintain accounts, we have been able to keep our U.S. clients’ existing Schwab Alliance accounts active when they eventually move abroad in the majority cases (with a few known jurisdictional exceptions). This is a shining example of why we encourage potential clients that are planning to move abroad to reach out to us well before they actually move. This may broaden the practical brokerage options.

Institutional-Only Brokerage Option

As independent advisors, we are not captive agents of any particular custodian. Our goal is to find the best practical custodial solutions for our clients, particularly in the more limited international client context. Accordingly, we work with other brokerages/custodians that further broaden our advisory capabilities to additional countries, broaden available investment options and/or offer the potential for clients to hold investments and cash in foreign currencies. As a result of our multiple-custodian reach, we are able to work with clients that are residents of almost every other country in the world that are not subject to sanction by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC).  

Beyond the ability to open and custody accounts with few geographic limitations, institutional-only brokerage options may offer additional benefits, including:

  • Less Trading Limitations – In fact, not only are ETFs available to clients in Europe, some options open the door to certain mutual funds, interval funds, private equity funds, etc. This is particularly useful for clients that want more access to alternative investments. Direct trading on foreign exchanges and multicurrency capabilities are also available for some custodial offerings.
  • International Transfer On Death – This may not offer the perfect solution in all cases, but a couple of institutional brokerages have created  an “international transfer on death” option for brokerage accounts that could simplify the otherwise complex and lengthy processes of transferring brokerage assets to heirs.

Banking Challenges for U.S. Expats

KYC / AML Rules

“Know Your Customer” and “Anti Money Laundering” laws require brokerages to verify who you are and where your money comes from. Customers living abroad are harder to verify.

The Patriot Act raised these standards significantly. Overseas clients create more compliance work, so many firms simply draw the line at the U.S. border.

Foreign Regulation

Serving customers in another country can mean complying with that country’s financial laws – on top of all US rules. Many U.S. financial institutions decide it’s not worth it.

Each foreign jurisdiction may require additional reporting, licensing or disclosures. Financial institutions conduct a cost/benefit analysis and many opt out entirely.

Complexity vs Scale

High regulatory risk and operational costs are not justified by the small size of the US – expat market.

U.S. expats are a small group spread across hundreds of different countries. Because they are so scattered and the numbers are low, only a few financial institutions bother to face the risk and complexity required to serve them.

The institutional-only brokerage options normally offer somewhat different client experiences, because the advisory firm is exclusively managing all trades and most if not all communication with the brokerage. However, that’s more than reasonable when you consider why the geographical and investment restrictions are eased in this arrangement:  the institutional-only brokerage is doing direct business in all aspects with the U.S. regulated and domiciled advisory firm (e.g., Walkner Condon) rather than the non-resident individual. Additionally, all of these added features (e.g., geographical reach, investment flexibility, multi-exchange, multi-currency and transfer on death) will come with some additional costs – commissions and fees may be somewhat higher than with Schwab or IB. 

There truly is no best solution for every expat. There are retail options for the majority of expats that remain retail, do-it-yourself investors. However, there are simply some countries where there are no clear retail brokerage options for U.S. expats and there are many additional countries where investment restrictions might force do-it-yourself expat investors to have to construct portfolios with individual securities (stocks and bonds). Such involved portfolios require more time, research, monitoring and investment knowledge than many retail investors have or wish to commit themselves to undertaking. Building truly diversified portfolios in such a manner is something that the advent of funds, particularly index funds and ETFs, made more simple and manageable for individuals and also their advisors. They are  relatively simple and efficient tools to attain understandable and meaningful diversification with relatively low costs – a staple for most investors.

On the other hand, adding the additional institutional options beyond the retail landscape for expats creates a state of affairs that dramatically expands the foreign residence geographies and the investment tools available to the expat investor. We realize that many expats may either want to direct their own investments or don’t meet the investment minimums to work with us or other financial advisors capable of directing their investments with knowledge and experience working with expats. It’s not a perfect U.S. brokerage world, but this is a sincere attempt to clarify and assist all expats trying to navigate that world. If you’d like to learn more about your options and might be interested in working with an advisor that specializes in working with U.S. expats, please visit our website, subscribe to our newsletter, and consider reaching out to schedule an appointment with someone on our expat team.

About the Author
Smiling man in business suit at Expat Walkner Condon Financial Advisors event.
Stan Farmer, CFP®, JDPartner | U.S. Expat Financial Advisor

Stan Farmer, J.D., is a Certified Financial Planner™ (CFP®) and fee-only financial advisor who specializes in working with Americans (and non-Americans) living outside the U.S.

You should always consult a financial, tax, or legal professional familiar about your unique circumstances before making any financial decisions. This material is intended for educational purposes only. Nothing in this material constitutes a solicitation for the sale or purchase of any securities. Any mentioned rates of return are historical or hypothetical in nature and are not a guarantee of future returns. Past performance does not guarantee future performance. Future returns may be lower or higher. Investments involve risk. Investment values will fluctuate with market conditions, and security positions, when sold, may be worth less or more than their original cost.

Share this:

Recent Posts