4.9% real GDP growth, 5% interest rates, 3.1% inflation, 3.7% unemployment, and S&P 500 up over 20% on the year.
Reading these numbers, you could easily think they belong to a bygone era when the US economy was soaring and good times were rolling, perhaps the roaring 1920s, the post-WWII expansion, or the mid 80’s and 90’s boom years. Yet, the figures listed above are official data as of the end of 2024, stellar numbers by most historical standards, but you would have no idea how good things are judging by the depressed mood among investors and the general public that prevailed throughout most of 2023.
Growth is back, we’re operating at full employment, inflation is only modestly higher than the Fed’s target, and long-suffering savers can finally enjoy some returns on their hard-earned cash. Yet investors have spent most of 2023 trapped in an endless cycle of recession worries, fearing the imminent start of the crisis so many market commentators had predicted. In last year’s Walkner Condon outlook(1) I had warned about this negativity bubble and the extreme bearish positioning. While economic improvements are finally getting some recognition, we started the year in such a gloomy state that perhaps it’s taken until now for people to start questioning whether things really were as bad as they were told. In a recent podcast, the New York Times referred to this disconnect as an “enduring mystery” and questioned ”Why do Americans feel so bad when the economy is so good?”(2) (a topic my colleagues Keith and Clint had already covered with much more panache in their own podcast(3)). The TikTok sphere, I am told, even has its own “silent depression” viral trend, purporting that we are in fact amid deep economic despair, there just haven’t been enough social media posts about it for people to notice(4).
The New Normal
We’ll never fully grasp the reasons for this ongoing negativity, but it’s worth mentioning that we have all been conditioned for doom and gloom in the last decade or so. After all, ever since the great financial crisis, we are supposed to be living in the “new normal”, a term coined by Mohamed El-Arian in 2009 to describe the low-growth post-crisis environment(5), and which has since become entrenched in investor parlance to describe the quantitative easing (QE) era: this strange experimental world where old dynamics no longer apply, where the gyrations of monetary interventionism have replaced business cycles, where low rates act as a form of ongoing subsidy, where any sign no economic weakness is met with drastic fiscal measures, and where none of this even matters anyway because inflation is dead(6).
Through the lens of the “new normal”, it’s hard to picture an economy driven by ongoing labor market strength, consumer spending and innovation. Yet one of the more surprising positive developments of the year, to me, has been the increase in labor productivity growth. In technical terms, labor productivity is defined as the total output of an economy divided by the total number of labor hours. In essence, it should simply capture how good we are at making stuff: if our business environment, policies, laws, financial conditions, labor practices and technology are conducive to growth, each unit of labor should be producing more. As such, labor productivity growth has the potential to be a sort of master economic number, a piece of data that looks through all the noise and if we’re moving in the right direction, the only piece of data you’ll ever need. In practice, things are a bit more complicated, in part because labor productivity is very hard to calculate, prone to wild swings and statistical noise.
With that said, ignoring the COVID distortions in the chart above(7), the Q3 2023 productivity reading of +4.7% was the highest quarterly increase recorded in over a decade and followed an already very respectable 3.6% in Q2.
If this trend can be sustained, it has profound implications for growth, and for the fight against inflation. To understand its relevance to inflation in particular, simply think about one of the most popular definitions of inflation: too much money chasing too few goods. If, in aggregate, the economy becomes better by making stuff, the money has more goods to chase, and inflation abates…
This improved productivity on the part of US workers and businesses has no doubt had a role to play in the recent improvements on the inflation front, though I’m sure central bankers will naturally take all the credit for it (I once attended a conference where a retired official described central banking as the world’s greatest self-congratulation society, I don’t think he was kidding). Growth, meanwhile, has also started increasing fairly significantly in recent months, as evidenced in the 4.9% third quarter estimate(8):
For these improvements to happen now, after a massive increase in interest rates, at a time when we are finally experiencing positive real (inflation adjusted) interest rates for the first time since the early 2000s (see chart below(9)), and while growth is rising (labor productivity often rising in recessions), is a clear sign that the “old normal” is new again and that we’ve just experienced a streak of very successful economic performance which many may have thought out of reach in our generation.
In short, we are back, and, economically at least, the future may be starting to look like the good old days of a not so distant past. Perhaps we are even re-discovery the merits of an old normal rate policy, where the higher cost of capital pushes businesses to be more efficient, starting with a purge of zombie businesses and bloated profitless startups we witnessed in 2023(10).
These gains in productivity and growth are ultimately the only “good” way to beat inflation, the only alternative to the standard central bank modus operandi: crushing the economy enough to kill inflation.
The New Old Market Trends
Another possible reason why it’s been so hard for investors to get excited about the economy and markets is the notable lack of breadth in this year’s rally. For most of the year, while markets did remarkably well overall, that performance was driven almost entirely by a small handful of large cap US stocks (now dubbed, the “Magnificent Seven”). Through October 2023, they had rallied over 50%, while the other 493 constituents of the index barely move(11).
So far in 2023 S&P7 is up more than 50%. S&P493 is basically flat.
Not that this type of market behavior is really anything new, we’ve seen many periods of highly concentrated market trends in the past. After all, when the first Back to the Future Movie came out in 1985, the world was in the midst of one of the greatest asset price bubbles in history: the Japanese stocks and real estate bubble. An episode that would see Japanese stocks grow to represent 42% of global markets and average Price/Earning ratio of 60 (for perspective, Japanese stocks now account for about 5% of global markets and a PE ratio of 16). While not as extreme, one may even find vague hints of that era in today’s extreme US-centric positioning. Of course, Marty McFly and Doc Brown could have propelled themselves into the late 90s for a taste of the internet stock craze, or gone back in time to the 60’s and experience the “Nifty Fifty” era(12), a blue chip stocks frenzy not unlike today’s mega cap tech obsession. Launching the DeLorean time machine back to the roaring 20s would have allowed an even wilder ride: an era dominated by exhilarating new technologies that saw the share price of RCA (The Radio Corporation of America) grow over 200-fold, outpacing even Nvidia’s performance in the last decade.
For the most part, all of these episodes were underpinned by genuine economic strength, but that did not prevent asset prices from becoming grossly overinflated, and for a crisis to eventually emerge. Current investor negativity, or at least skepticism, has the merit of keeping expectations in check, and valuations somewhat realistic. Sentiments are fickle and can change on a dime, as I’m typing this on the last trading day of 2023, markets are hovering around all-time highs, and a further breakout would surely lead to a deluge of enthusiastic headlines. As of late, we also witnessed a broadening of the rally, with small cap and dividend paying stocks beginning to catch up with the magnificent 7, even much hated bonds have rallied as interest rates fell. If this trend continues, even the most hardened of bears may have no choice but to throw in the towel. The goldilocks narrative could easily start to take hold take hold: imagine a magical place in the not so distant future where AI revolution meets falling rates and inflation, and where recession fears have morphed into soft landing realities. What’s not to like? With just a little bit more patience this future may well be within reach, even without a DeLorean.
The More Things Change
With all that said, I certainly don’t think we are out of the woods when it comes to central bank induced-recession risk. As impressive as the streak of economic strength has been, betting on its indefinite continuation would be betting on something that has never been achieved at any time in the 100 or so years of the central banking era: strong, consistent growth that lasts. Indeed, all prior periods of economic strength mentioned in this article ultimately had one thing in common: they ended in distorted asset prices and in some form of a crisis, one way or another.
One of the more absurd sounding things I told my colleagues in private office discussions last year (which was never meant to leave these walls) was something along the lines of “bank collapses are bullish”. This pronouncement was made in response to worries that the SVP bankruptcy was going to trigger the next crisis. As flippant and ridiculous as it sounded back then, in hindsight, I was right. I didn’t mean to imply that business failure was, in itself, a good thing, but that if it triggered central bank easing, it may be an upside catalyst.
While it might be easy to imagine that bank failures, higher rates and central bank balance sheet reduction would cause severe tightening of financial conditions, the NFCI index actually indicates the opposite: financial conditions in the U.S. have been constantly loosening over the course of 2023(13):
This counterintuitive development may be explained in part by short-term liquidity measures put in place in response to SVB collapse, such as the ever popular Bank Term Funding Program in the US , and various liquidity supporting measures by central bank counterparts around the world (the Chinese’s central bank’s asset have grown $600B in the last 4 months (14)):
All perhaps cumulating to or what macro analysts Matt King calls “Saying QT but doing QE”:

Meanwhile, as if these loosening financial conditions weren’t enough, the market is now pricing in an aggressive succession of rate cuts in 2024. Market-derived odds apply the highest probability outcomes to no less than 7 rate cuts of the course of 2024(16).

With the term funding program now set to expire in March, and with plenty of strong economic data to support a higher-for-longer Fed policy stance, one might wonder how much longer the goldilocks conditions of loosening liquidity and aggressive rate cut expectations might last. For economic strength to persist, it may need to survive a tighter than expected financial environment, and it may also have to deal with one of its main ongoing challenges: continued tight labor supply.
Still No One Left to Hire
While full employment conditions are generally seen as a positive, they also have a dark side to them. In the short term, tight labor markets have supported wage growth and spending, contributing to growth, but they also create a difficult equilibrium for businesses: a combination of higher costs, and difficulty in planning future expansion. Some of the positive developments on the labor productivity metrics discussed earlier are certainly rooted in business response to having to do more with less, with fewer staff, but how much more can we squeeze out of our existing workforce? At some point, businesses may need to start scaling back their plans or delaying expansion until conditions improve. If hiring slows and financial conditions tighten, it would not take long for the goldilocks environment to shift to much, much more challenging conditions.
Throughout 2023, I have repeatedly told skeptical clients that I believed the rally that started in October 2022 had legs. As we enter 2024, I still believe this to be the case. Strong economic data and earnings, still tepid investor sentiments, a shift in rate policy and slower inflation are likely to continue to support the current bullish momentum. At the same time, while all the talk of recession that dominated headlines at the beginning of the year has financially started to subside, recession probabilities have, in my view, increased compared to the same time last year. As prices go up, there is always a temptation to believe that this time will truly be different. AI is already emerging as a justification for ever-expanding valuation in a small subset of the market, but a look at our past may very well provide clues to what the future holds. If history is any guide, 2024 could be both fantastically exciting, and dangerous.
Sources
- Walkner Condon – 2023 Market Outlook
- New York TImes – The Bad Vibes Around a Good Economy (podcast)
- Walkner Condon – Gimme Some Truth Podcast – Consumer Sentiment
- CNBC – Is the U.S. in a Silent Depression
- Business Insider – Global Stagflation
- The Economist – The Death of Inflation
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics – Nonfarm business labor productivity
- U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis – Gross Domestic Product
- Federal Reserve Economic Data – Ten Year Interest Rate
- CNBC – Startup Bubble Fueled by Cheap Money Policy
- Valerie Noel on LinkedIn – Evaluating your 2023 returns against the S&P 500
- Investopedia – Nifty Fifty: What it is and How it Works
- Federal Reserve Economic Data – Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index
- Otavio (Tavi) Costa, Macro Strategist at Crescat on LinkedIn – Global Fiat Debasement
- Matt King on LinkedIn – Wondering Why Risk Assets Have Performed So Well This Year
- The Kobeissi Letter
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statisics – Number of unemployed persons per job opening, seasonally adjusted

